Welcome back, everyone! Today’s food review dives into Jimmy John’s Picklewich—a limited-time twist on a sandwich where a jumbo pickle stands in for the bread. Jimmy John’s offers this “pickle as a bun” creation in two flavors: Vito and Turkey. I decided to give both a shot, so here’s my take on each, from flavor to practicality (spoiler: you’re going to want napkins).
What is the Jimmy John’s Picklewich?
The Picklewich is exactly what it sounds like: a hollowed-out pickle stuffed with sandwich fillings. Jimmy John’s launched this as a low-carb, novelty option, which is sure to excite pickle fans. Here’s the breakdown of each flavor:
- The Vito Picklewich: Filled with salami, capicola, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, a dash of sauce, and herbs.
- The Turkey Picklewich: Packed with turkey, provolone, lettuce, tomato, and topped with some Jimmy John’s signature sauce.
For those of us who are skipping the carbs but love the tang of a pickle, this concept is intriguing. But, does it actually work? Let’s dig in.
First Impressions: Vito Picklewich
I started with the Vito Picklewich. Unwrapping it, I was hit with that strong pickle aroma—and yes, it was very wet with pickle juice. Weighing in at 9.7 ounces, it’s lighter than a typical Jimmy John’s sub. The filling looked appetizing, though my plate was already soaked before I even took a bite. They give it to you wrapped, which I removed for the sake of this review. I suggest leaving that wrapper on!
Once I bit in, I was greeted by a satisfying crunch that bread simply can’t deliver. The Vito’s strong flavors of salami and capicola complemented the sharp, briny pickle well. However, be warned: it’s a juicy experience, so you may want to keep the wrapper on as much as possible to help manage the drips.
Moving On to the Turkey Picklewich
Next, I tried the Turkey Picklewich, which weighed a bit lighter at 9.4 ounces. Much like the Vito, it was juicy and crunchy, but I noticed that the more subtle turkey flavor didn’t stand up to the pickle quite as well as the Vito’s bold ingredients. The pickle’s flavor is front and center here, with the turkey and cheese somewhat playing second fiddle.
The Verdict
Between the two, I’d go with the Vito Picklewich. The combination of Italian meats with a dill pickle adds a rich contrast that works in this unconventional sandwich. The turkey version wasn’t bad, but it didn’t have the same level of flavor balance as the Vito.
Would I buy this again? For $7.79 each, it’s a little pricey considering it’s essentially a pickle stuffed with sandwich ingredients. But for a low-carb option or something a bit different, it’s a fun choice. And for true pickle lovers, the crunch and tang of this unique “sandwich” might be enough to win you over.
Final Thoughts
Overall, I found the Jimmy John’s Picklewich to be a fun twist on the sandwich. It’s a bit messy and drippy, but that’s part of the charm (if you’re okay with a little pickle juice). I wouldn’t mind seeing this as a seasonal offering, and I’d probably go for it again.
Have you tried the Picklewich or anything similar? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below! Thanks for reading, and see you next time.
Video Review
Below you can watch my full review of the Picklewich!