Looking for the perfect toaster can feel like a daunting task, especially when you’re comparing two highly-rated models with a significant price gap. Recently, I set out to find a toaster that would not only deliver perfectly browned toast but also last longer than my previous high-end model. After hours of testing, here’s how the Buydeem ($70) and Breville ($210) four-slot toasters stack up.
Where to Purchase
Below are links where you can purchase the items covered in this review, plus the cute tongs I used in my video.
Initial Impressions and Features
Buydeem: Budget-Friendly with Classic Features
The Buydeem toaster is a manual four-slot toaster with straightforward functionality. It features a lever for lowering bread, along with dedicated buttons for canceling, bagels, defrosting, and reheating. The reheat function is particularly impressive, warming toast without additional browning—a lifesaver for leisurely breakfasts.
Notable details:
- Browning Levels: A dial ranges from 1 to 7.
- Bagel Mode: Toasts only the cut side.
- Ease of Use: Straightforward controls, though the simplicity may appeal more to minimalists.
Breville: Premium Price, Premium Features
The Breville toaster embraces modern technology, with fully automated bread lowering and an LED slider indicating browning levels. Unique features like the “Lift and Look” and “A Bit More” options set it apart, making it ideal for the perfectionist.
Notable details:
- Browning Levels: Five visible levels with 12 incremental adjustments.
- Automation: Bread automatically lowers and rises.
- Additional Features: A plug with a built-in finger loop for easy removal—a small but thoughtful design touch.
The Toasting Tests
Round 1: Low, Medium, and High Settings
I tested each toaster at the lowest, medium, and highest browning settings, using generic white bread.
- Buydeem:
- Low Setting: Lightly toasted, with a noticeable but subtle crunch.
- Medium Setting: Even browning across slices.
- High Setting: Toasted to a deep brown without excessive smoke—a reliable performer.
- Breville:
- Low Setting: Similar results to the Buydeem, with evenly distributed heat.
- Medium Setting: Slightly less even compared to the Buydeem, though still consistent.
- High Setting: Toasted darker than the Buydeem, with a bit more smoke. Some slices bordered on burnt but remained acceptable.
Verdict: The Buydeem offered slightly more even results on medium settings, while the Breville’s darker high setting might appeal to those who prefer bold toast.
Round 2: Frozen Waffles
For this test, I used frozen waffles to see how each toaster handled the defrost function.
- Buydeem: Quickly defrosted and toasted the waffles evenly, with no cold spots.
- Breville: Took longer but produced waffles with an even crispness and golden-brown hue.
Verdict: Both performed well, but the Breville edged out the Buydeem with slightly superior crispness.
Round 3: Bagels
Both toasters promised to toast the inside of bagels while leaving the outer surface warm.
- Buydeem: Delivered nicely browned interiors with slightly warm exteriors.
- Breville: Identical results, though the process felt smoother thanks to the automated lowering feature.
Verdict: A tie. Both toasters excelled in this round.
Unique Features and Final Thoughts
Buydeem: Reheat Function
The reheat button is a standout, allowing you to warm up toast without further browning. Perfect for slow mornings when breakfast is delayed.
Breville: “Lift and Look” & “A Bit More”
The “Lift and Look” feature lets you check toast mid-cycle without canceling the process, while “A Bit More” adds a touch more time if your toast isn’t quite ready. These features are small but impactful, adding convenience and precision.
Conclusion: Which Toaster Wins?
Both the Buydeem and Breville toasters are excellent choices, but your decision will depend on your priorities:
- Buydeem ($70): Ideal for those who want a simple, reliable toaster with a handy reheat function. It’s affordable and performs consistently well, making it a great value.
- Breville ($210): Perfect for tech enthusiasts or those who love added convenience. The automated functions and refined features justify the higher price, especially if you’re picky about precision.
For me, the Breville won by a slim margin due to its versatility and modern features, though the Buydeem is a close runner-up. Whichever you choose, you’ll be starting your day with perfectly toasted bread!
Have you tried either of these toasters? Tell me what you think in the comments below.
Video Review
Check out the full video review below.